![]() The main reason for this is that combat has always been infused with a tremendous amount of luck. Please realize that just because one ship scores 'more points' than another ship in my rating system does not necessarily mean that it would always 'win' in a fight against a lower-ranked vessel. "Does a higher rating mean that ship is always gonna win.?" 'If it looks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it's a duck', my friend. The Brits certainly treated her like a battleship. ![]() That's what the big 'boom-booms' on the front are for duh. You can call her anything you like, but she was designed for capital ship combat. ![]() No, Bismarck had big guns, and heavy armor, and expensive fire-control systems because she was designed to beat up other capital ships that got in her way when she was chasing the aforementioned merchantmen. Any light cruiser can do the same job at a tenth the cost. ![]() So what? They still had to be able to tangle with the other guy's large warships and come out on top, or why bother expending the prodigious quantities of resources necessary to construct them? It's hardly necessary to put 15" weapons and heavy armor on a warship intended to scupper unarmored merchantmen armed with nothing bigger than a 5" gun. Face it all of these battleships had slightly different missions because of the national policy objectives of their building countries and the varying theatres of action they would likely operate in. My answer: just because you rename a ship and call it a 'commerce raider' means nothing, changes nothing. I loved this statement when I got it the other day. She shouldn't be compared to other battleships!" "But Bismarck was built as a commerce raider. She's just not a very good design, is all. ![]() Let's start off with one of my favorites. Herein I have tried to lay out answers to some of the more frequently asked questions about the "Best Battleship Comparison", as well as substantiate my sources. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |